Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Liz's avatar

I bought Careless People solely because someone told me not to. But! I appreciated your context. I’m legal and thus in the business of periodically making decisions where people think they know why and, after the game of “legal said” telephone completes, the original rationale is gone. Obviously comms can be improved but, at least in my experience, most of the time my reaction is surprise because no one ever came to me, a team member or, if applicable channels, to privately or anonymous disclose concerns.

Are power dynamics involved? Sure, and that might be a fair reason why one didn’t ask in the moment, but it should be checked prior to publication (I am not making any judgment about the veracity of the book as I haven’t read it yet.)

As long as we’re sharing:

* Re-reading Snow Crash

* “Regulating Bodies” by Jaime Schultz

* “A Dynamic Governance Model for AI” at Lawfare: https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/a-dynamic-governance-model-for-ai

* Rando game theory shit because I am apoplectic at capitulation by large institutions, especially law firms, and shout into the void in my own Substack because I am too old for LiveJournal.

Expand full comment
Brand Newsroom's avatar

Speaking as a total stranger, I wouldn’t ever tell you to shut up. But I do have to say that I’m no longer listening. I thought you had generally been a voice of sanity and honesty in forthrightly highlighting how social media — and your former employer in particular— has wreaked so much destruction in U.S. political culture and around the world.

But rather than being cautious, your tone came across as the censorious one you label your own critics with. In contrast to the nuanced Steven Levy review you pointed to, your criticism of “Careless People” has largely boiled down to “this isn’t what I saw” without being part of the particular incidents Sarah Wynn-Williams mentions in the book.

While I can understand different experiences with the same people, and I can appreciate loyalty to those who treated you well. your defense of Joel Kaplan seems suspect to me, given the abrupt about face Facebook has taken regarding policing dis- and misinformation and hate speech.

That said, I have no plans to buy Wynn-Williams book, but until I see some actual evidence of her inaccuracies and her response, I will continue to be against those who want to shut her and her book up.

I hope you’ll once again contribute more thoughtful criticism with the platform you’ve built.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts